How to Start a Nonprofit Thrift Store: Tax, Safety and Receipts
A nonprofit thrift store pays no tax on its profit if substantially all of what it sells was donated or its staff are volunteers; buying stock or taking consignments with paid staff can break that. It must not sell recalled items, and its receipts describe donations without valuing them.
A charity thrift store looks like a simple business: people donate, you sell, the money goes to the mission. Three rules make it different from any other shop. The tax code lets you sell donated goods without tax on the profit, but only while substantially all of what you sell was donated or your staff are volunteers. Federal product-safety law makes it illegal to sell a recalled item, and some used children’s products must be destroyed rather than sold. And donors will ask you what their bag of clothes was worth, which is a question you must not answer. This guide covers those, with the state rules and the numbers. The general formation steps are in how to start a nonprofit.
Charity thrift stores, by the numbers
The Census Bureau’s County Business Patterns counts employer businesses by legal form. Our extraction of its 2023 file for used merchandise stores finds that nonprofits run a third of the establishments but employ more than half the workers:
| Used merchandise stores (NAICS 453310) | All | Nonprofit | Nonprofit share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Establishments, 2023 | 19,466 | 6,506 | 33.4% |
| Employees, 2023 | 222,478 | 118,443 | 53.2% |
| Annual payroll, 2023 | $5.46 billion | $2.91 billion | 53.3% |
| Establishments, 2022 | 19,186 | 6,411 | 33.4% |
Those counts include only stores with paid staff, so all-volunteer shops are missing. The large networks are run locally: Habitat for Humanity says there are more than 900 ReStore locations, independently owned by local affiliates, and Goodwill reports that its local organizations recovered the value of more than 4.6 billion pounds of used goods in 2025. Waste is the other side of the trade: the EPA estimated that only 14.7 percent of textiles were recycled in 2018, out of about 17 million tons generated, while landfills received 11.3 million tons. What a store cannot sell or pass on joins that stream, which is why disposal belongs in the budget.
The tax rule that makes a thrift store work
Running a shop is usually an unrelated business, and its profit is taxed. A thrift store escapes that through one of two exceptions in the tax code. The first covers “selling of merchandise, substantially all of which has been received … as gifts”; the regulations say this exception applies to “so-called thrift shops operated by a tax-exempt organization”, and the IRS’s own page notes that many thrift shop operations would meet this exception. The second covers any business where substantially all the work is done without compensation.
| How the store is run | Tax position on sales | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Sells donated goods, paid staff | Not unrelated business: the donated merchandise exception | IRS Pub 598 |
| Run entirely by volunteers, any goods | Not unrelated business: the volunteer labor exception | IRS letter 00-0404 |
| Paid staff, buys stock or takes consignments | Sales of those goods can be unrelated business income | IRS letter 12-0024 |
| A separate corporation raising money for several charities | Can itself qualify under 501(c)(3) | Rev. Rul. 71-581 |
The two exceptions are separate, and the difference matters as the store grows. The IRS explained in a ruling letter that a business run entirely by volunteers may purchase or manufacture inventory for sale, and that a store selling only donated goods may still hire paid staff. But a store with paid staff that starts buying stock loses the donated-goods exception on those sales. Consignment is the common trap: the IRS has said that a consignment shop selling merchandise “substantially all of which is not received as gifts” does not meet the exclusion. The IRS sets no percentage for “substantially all”; keep purchased and consigned goods a small, tracked share of sales, or keep them out entirely. How unrelated business income is reported if you do cross the line is in can a nonprofit sell products.
A store can also be its own organization. In Revenue Ruling 71-581 the IRS recognized a separately incorporated thrift shop that raised money for several charities, where “substantially all of the merchandise sold” had been contributed, and the feeder organization rules in section 502 apply the same donated-goods exception to it.
Donor receipts: describe, never value
Donors of goods can deduct their value, and they will ask you to put a number on the receipt. Do not. The IRS’s guidance for charities says a written acknowledgment includes “a description (but not the fair market value)” of donated property. Valuing it is the donor’s job: Publication 526 says the value of used clothing and household items is generally the price that buyers of used items actually pay in used clothing stores, and gives the example of a coat bought for $300 and deductible at $50. Publication 561 adds that valuation of clothing does not lend itself to fixed formulas. Donors can deduct clothing and household items only if they are in good used condition or better, under section 170(f)(16).
Two forms reach the store. Donors claiming more than $500 of noncash gifts file Form 8283; above $5,000 for an item or group of similar items they need a qualified appraisal, and the charity signs Section B, which the IRS says is not an appraisal and does not represent agreement with the claimed value. If the store then sells an item reported in Section B within three years, it files Form 8282 to report the disposition. Few thrift donations reach that level, but a donated antique or vehicle can. Our donation receipt template has the wording, and how in-kind gifts are recorded is in in-kind donations.
Product safety: what you cannot sell
The Consumer Product Safety Commission’s guide for resellers applies to “thrift stores, consignment stores, charities, and individuals holding yard sales”, and is blunt: it is illegal to sell any recalled product. Resellers do not have to test what they sell, but they cannot sell products that do not meet the law. The rules that catch thrift stores most:
- Recalls. Check donations against the CPSC recall list, especially children’s products, and pull anything recalled.
- Cribs. Destroy cribs made before 28 June 2011 unless you have written proof they meet the current standard. The guide says absolutely no drop-side cribs may be sold.
- Children’s products. Lead is limited to 100 parts per million in accessible parts, and certain phthalates in toys and child care articles to 0.1%.
- Drawstrings. Remove hood and neck drawstrings from children’s upper outerwear in sizes 2T to 12, and make sure waist drawstrings are free of toggles and knots at the ends.
The simplest policy is to refuse cribs, car seats and other high-risk children’s items. Goodwill notes that many Goodwill organizations do not accept mattresses, and in California used bedding must carry “SECONDHAND (USED)” labels and be sanitized before sale, according to the state’s bedding labeling guidance. A published acceptance list protects volunteers and saves disposal costs.
State rules: sales tax and secondhand dealer laws
Whether you collect sales tax on thrift sales depends on the state, and most do not exempt it. North Carolina ruled that a charity’s thrift store is a retailer and that all of its sales are subject to North Carolina sales and use tax, even though the charity itself is exempt; its once-a-year sale exemption does not cover a store open every week. Other states exempt some charity sales. Check your state’s revenue department before you open, and register to collect if required; how state exemptions work is in nonprofit sales tax exemption.
Many states license secondhand dealers and pawn shops, with reporting rules for used goods. Some exempt charities: Florida’s secondhand dealer law, for example, does not apply to transactions involving an organization registered with the state as nonprofit, religious or charitable. Check your state’s law and any city license before signing a lease.
Running the store
- Space. Retail frontage, a donation drop-off with parking, and back-room space for sorting.
- Staffing. Volunteer-run stores keep the volunteer labor exception. If you hire, the wage and hour rules apply, and paid staff cannot volunteer extra hours doing the same work; see nonprofit HR and how to recruit volunteers.
- Pricing and turnover. Price to sell within weeks, rotate stock, and have a plan for what does not sell: textile recyclers, other charities, or disposal.
- Cash controls. A shop handles cash every day. Two-person counts, daily deposits and a reconciled till are the basics; our internal controls template covers them.
- Insurance. General liability for customers and volunteers, property cover for stock, and product liability. What nonprofits typically pay is in nonprofit insurance cost.
The steps, in order
- Decide the model. Donated goods with paid staff, all-volunteer, or a separate corporation serving several charities.
- Form the nonprofit and apply for 501(c)(3) status, describing the store as a fundraising activity for the mission. State fees are in the state guides.
- Check state and local rules: sales tax registration, secondhand dealer licensing, zoning and any bedding rules.
- Write an acceptance policy that excludes recalled and high-risk items, and a sorting procedure that checks recalls.
- Set up receipts that describe items without values, and a process for Form 8283 and 8282.
- Find the space, insure it, and set cash controls before the first sale.
Mistakes new stores make
- Buying stock or taking consignments with paid staff. It can turn tax-free sales into unrelated business income.
- Putting values on receipts. The donor values the gift; the charity describes it.
- Selling recalled items or old cribs. Illegal, and a real risk to children.
- Assuming nonprofit status exempts sales from sales tax. In many states it does not.
- Underestimating disposal. Much of what is donated cannot be sold.
More on how charities earn income is in how nonprofits make money, and other sector start-up guides cover animal rescues, youth sports and art galleries.
Questions people ask
How do I start a nonprofit thrift store?
Form a nonprofit and apply for 501(c)(3) status, decide whether the store sells only donated goods or is run by volunteers, register for sales tax if your state requires it, check secondhand dealer and zoning rules, write an acceptance policy that excludes recalled items, and set up receipts and cash controls.
Do nonprofit thrift stores pay tax on their profits?
Usually not. Selling merchandise substantially all of which was donated is excluded from unrelated business income, and so is a business run substantially by volunteers. A store with paid staff that buys stock or takes consignments can owe tax on those sales.
Can a nonprofit thrift store sell consigned or new items?
Carefully. The IRS has said a consignment shop selling goods substantially all of which were not donated does not meet the donated-merchandise exclusion. An all-volunteer store may buy inventory under the separate volunteer exception.
Should a thrift store put a value on donation receipts?
No. IRS guidance says the acknowledgment describes donated property but not its fair market value. The donor values it, generally at what used items sell for in thrift stores.
What can a thrift store not sell?
Any recalled product, cribs made before 28 June 2011 without proof they meet the current standard, drop-side cribs, and children's products over the lead and phthalate limits, according to the Consumer Product Safety Commission's guide for resellers.
Do nonprofit thrift stores charge sales tax?
In many states, yes. North Carolina, for example, ruled that a charity's thrift store is a retailer and its sales are taxable. Some states exempt certain charity sales, so check your state's revenue department.
How many thrift stores are nonprofits?
Census Bureau data for 2023 show nonprofits ran 6,506 of 19,466 used merchandise stores with paid staff, a third of them, and employed 53% of the workers. All-volunteer shops are not counted.
What is Form 8282 and does a thrift store need it?
Form 8282 reports the sale of donated property worth more than $5,000 that a donor reported on Form 8283 Section B, if the charity sells it within three years. Most thrift donations are far below that.
Does a nonprofit thrift store need a secondhand dealer license?
It depends on the state and city. Florida's secondhand dealer law, for example, does not apply to registered nonprofit, religious or charitable organizations. Check your state and local rules.
This is reference information, not legal or tax advice. Rules vary by state and change over time. For a decision that carries real consequences, check the current text at irs.gov or your state registry, and talk to a nonprofit attorney or CPA.